Disbelief Quote by Amy Bloom
““In stories, when someone behaves uncharacteristically, we take it as a meaningful, even pivotal moment. If we are surprised again and again, we have to keep changing our minds, or give up and disbelieve the writer. In real life, if people think they know you well enough not only to say, 'It's Tuesday, Amy must be helping out at the library today,' but well enough to say to the librarian, after you've left the building, 'You know, Amy just loves reading to the four-year-olds, I think it's been such a comfort for her since her little boy died'—if they know you like that, you can do almost anything where they can't see you, and when they hear about it, they will, as we do, simply disbelieve the narrator.””
About This Quote
Source Essay: “The Narrative Gap” in The New Yorker, 2018
She argues that unexpected character actions force readers to reassess narratives, mirroring how people can be misunderstood in real life.
In simple terms: Surprising actions reveal hidden depths and challenge assumptions.
Key Takeaway
Stay open to revising judgments.
Themes
storytelling
identity
perception
trust
misunderstanding
Mood
analytical
thoughtful
inquisitive
Type
literary
philosophical
When to use this quote
- personal relationships
- literary analysis
- media criticism
Key Concepts
narrative theory
psychology
social cognition
Questions to Reflect On
- How do you respond when someone acts out of character?
- What role does narrative play in shaping reality?
A Different Perspective
Overemphasis on surprise can ignore consistent traits.
