Absence Quote by Alfred Binet
“Mere numbers cannot bring out ... the intimate essence of the experiment. This conviction comes naturally when one watches a subject at work. ... What things can happen! What reflections, what remarks, what feelings, or, on the other hand, what blind automatism, what absence of ideas! ... The experimenter judges what may be going on in [the subject's] mind, and certainly feels difficulty in expressing all the oscillations of a thought in a simple, brutal number, which can have only a deceptive precision. How, in fact, could it sum up what would need several pages of description!”
About This Quote
Source Book: The Principles of Psychology by William James, 1890 (cited by Binet)
The quote argues that quantitative data cannot fully capture the nuanced, subjective experience of mental processes, which require rich description.
In simple terms: Numbers alone miss the depth of mental life.
Key Takeaway
Combine quantitative and qualitative methods in research.
Themes
psychology
measurement
subjectivity
methodology
Mood
analytical
reflective
Type
academic
philosophical
When to use this quote
- psychological research
- clinical assessment
- educational testing
- scientific reporting
Key Concepts
limitations of quantification
subjective experience
experimental observation
Questions to Reflect On
- How can researchers honor both numbers and narrative?
- What are the risks of relying solely on metrics?
A Different Perspective
Quantitative data may oversimplify complex thoughts.
![“[W]hen we look at the graphs of rising ocean temperatures, rising carbon dioxide in the atmosphere and so on, we know that they are climbing far more steeply than can be accounted for by the natural oscillation of the weather ... What people (must) do is to change their behavior and their…” quote by David Attenborough](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/img-quotes/04d/david-attenborough-2396_atmosphere_w-hen-we-look-at-the-graphs-of-rising-oc_1110905.jpg)
![“The observations, so numerous and so important, of the pendulum as object are especially relevant to the length of its oscillations. Those that I propose to make known to the [Paris] Academy [of Sciences] are principally addressed to the direction of the plane of its oscillation, which, moving…” quote by Leon Foucault](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/img-quotes/e85/leon-foucault-85526_academy_the-observations-so-numerous-and-so-impo_870149.jpg)
![“I wish that one would be persuaded that psychological experiments, especially those on the complex functions, are not improved [by large studies]; the statistical method gives only mediocre results; some recent examples demonstrate that. The American authors, who love to do things big, often…” quote by Alfred Binet](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/img-quotes/8cd/alfred-binet-37082_american-author_i-wish-that-one-would-be-persuaded-that_712063.jpg)
