Skip to content

It is only in times of social dissolution, as in the last…

“It is only in times of social dissolution, as in the last age of the small Semitic states, when men and their gods were alike powerless before the advance of the Assyrians, that magical superstitions based on mere terror, or rites designed to conciliate alien gods, invade the sphere of tribal or…” quote by William Robertson Smith
Download Open image
“It is only in times of social dissolution, as in the last age of the small Semitic states, when men and their gods were alike powerless before the advance of the Assyrians, that magical superstitions based on mere terror, or rites designed to conciliate alien gods, invade the sphere of tribal or national religion. In better times the religion of the tribe or state has nothing in common with the private and foreign superstitions or magical rites that savage terror may dictate to the individual.”

William Robertson Smith

About This Quote

This interpretation was drafted with AI assistance. It is one reading of the quote, not the author's own explanation.

During societal collapse, people turn to fear‑based magic and foreign rites, while stable societies keep religion separate from such superstitions.

In simple terms: Crises cause people to adopt magical superstitions; stable times keep religion pure.

Key Takeaway

Maintain rational belief systems in turmoil.

Themes

religion social change magic power dynamics

Mood

analytical historical

Type

scholarly explanatory

When to use this quote

  • political upheaval
  • community crises
  • religious reform

Key Concepts

cultural anthropology mythology political theory

Questions to Reflect On

  • What drives societies toward superstition in crisis?
  • Can stable societies ever be immune to fear‑based rites?
A Different Perspective

It may oversimplify complex historical causes.

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ No ratings yet

More by William Robertson Smith

Explore all 20 William Robertson Smith quotes

More Age quotes

Browse all 18,948 Age quotes