Skip to content

I also spoke about the kid who can’t be bothered to get…

“I also spoke about the kid who can’t be bothered to get A’s in every class in high school because they’re actually more interested in following their curiosity, so here’s another rule of thumb. U.S. News supplies the percentage of freshmen at each college who finished in the highest 10 percent of…” quote by William Deresiewicz
Download Open image
““I also spoke about the kid who can’t be bothered to get A’s in every class in high school because they’re actually more interested in following their curiosity, so here’s another rule of thumb. U.S. News supplies the percentage of freshmen at each college who finished in the highest 10 percent of their high school class. Among the top twenty universities, the number is usually above 90 percent, a threshold that is also reached at several of the top colleges. I’d be wary of schools like that (though I would make an exception for public universities, which draw from disadvantaged high schools from across their respective states). Not every ten-percenter is an excellent sheep, but a sufficient number are for you to think very carefully before deciding to surround yourself with them.””

William Deresiewicz

About This Quote

This interpretation was drafted with AI assistance. It is one reading of the quote, not the author's own explanation.

The author warns that elite academic credentials don't always indicate true intellectual curiosity, urging careful evaluation of peers

In simple terms: High grades at top schools don’t guarantee genuine curiosity

Key Takeaway

Look beyond rankings to assess genuine curiosity and fit

Themes

education critical thinking social dynamics

Mood

thoughtful cautious

Type

analytical advisory

When to use this quote

  • college admissions
  • peer groups
  • career planning

Key Concepts

meritocracy selection bias

Questions to Reflect On

  • What criteria truly indicate curiosity?
  • How do you balance prestige with personal growth?
A Different Perspective

Prestige can mask lack of curiosity

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ No ratings yet

More by William Deresiewicz

Explore all 42 William Deresiewicz quotes

More Education quotes

Browse all 37,666 Education quotes