The best (remedy) I can devise would be to give future…
“The best (remedy) I can devise would be to give future commissions to (federal) judges for six years with a re-appointability by the President with the approbation of both houses. If this would not be independence enough, I know not what would be.”
About This Quote
This interpretation was drafted with AI assistance. It is one reading of the quote, not the author's own explanation.
The author suggests appointing federal judges for six‑year terms with re‑appointment by the President and Senate approval to ensure independence.
In simple terms: Proposes limited, renewable judicial terms with checks.
Key Takeaway
Consider term limits with bipartisan oversight.
Themes
government
judiciary
independence
Mood
analytical
critical
Type
policy
philosophical
When to use this quote
- legislative proposals
- court appointments
- political negotiations
- constitutional debates
Key Concepts
checks and balances
judicial reform
Questions to Reflect On
- Would term limits improve or hinder judicial impartiality?
- What safeguards could prevent politicization?
A Different Perspective
Short terms may increase political pressure on judges.