Skip to content

I do not agree with you," insisted Georyn. "Must a man…

“I do not agree with you," insisted Georyn. "Must a man then live always as his fellows live, and never reach beyond? There is more to knowledge than you dream of, Terwyn, and if it lies in some enchanted realm- well, I think that there is a door to that realm. And I think that the Enchantress…” quote by Sylvia Louise Engdahl
Download Open image
““I do not agree with you," insisted Georyn. "Must a man then live always as his fellows live, and never reach beyond? There is more to knowledge than you dream of, Terwyn, and if it lies in some enchanted realm- well, I think that there is a door to that realm. And I think that the Enchantress knows where the door is and can open it." "Perhaps; but will she leave it open? Think, Georyn: even if she should let you look for such a door, the time will surely come when it will be sealed again; and when that happens you will not be on her side of it, but on ours. How will you feel then? Let us accept her help against the Dragon, but no more- for we are men, not wizards" "I am not sure," said Georyn, "that there is such a difference between the two.””

Sylvia Louise Engdahl

About This Quote

This interpretation was drafted with AI assistance. It is one reading of the quote, not the author's own explanation.

Two characters discuss the limits of knowledge, magic, and destiny, questioning whether to rely on enchanted aid or personal agency.

In simple terms: Debate over using magic versus human effort.

Key Takeaway

Balance curiosity with responsibility.

Themes

knowledge magic destiny agency choice

Mood

thoughtful conflicted inquisitive

Type

dialogue philosophical

When to use this quote

  • academic discussion
  • role‑playing game scenario
  • creative writing workshop
  • philosophical debate
  • storytelling session

Key Concepts

philosophy fantasy worldbuilding character conflict

Questions to Reflect On

  • When is it wise to accept supernatural help?
  • What are the risks of relying on external forces?
A Different Perspective

The dialogue may oversimplify complex ethical dilemmas.

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ No ratings yet

More Enchantress quotes

Browse all 18 Enchantress quotes