Skip to content

Now, in the academy, you cannot just say anything about…

“Now, in the academy, you cannot just say anything about male theory. You have to proceed with an immanent critique, that is to say, you have to expertly play the parts against the whole. You show, for example, how certain assumptions in the work actually defeat its stated purpose of human…” quote by Somer Brodribb
Download Open image
““Now, in the academy, you cannot just say anything about male theory. You have to proceed with an immanent critique, that is to say, you have to expertly play the parts against the whole. You show, for example, how certain assumptions in the work actually defeat its stated purpose of human liberation, but once remedied, i.e. salvaged, the theory will work for women. An immanent critique can stay within the masculinist academic circle. In this position women become the technicians of male theory who have to reprogram the machine, turning it from a war machine against women into a gentler, kinder war machine, killing us softly. This is a very involving task and after years of playing this part it is understandable that there may be little desire to admit that the effort was virtually futile. An investment has been made, and the conformity is not wholly outer. What attitudes and feelings does this sexist context produce towards oppositional women who refuse this male material? Does a male-circled woman have the power and security to be generous? Having compromised her freedom, will she be less willing to compromise ours? Perhaps the most pernicious aspect of this arrangement, besides the ways it sets women against one another, is the fact that although the male academy values owning our freedom, it does not have to pay a lot for it. Masculine culture already controls gross amounts of female lives. Still, it seems to want more, but always at the same low price. The exploited are very affordable.””

Somer Brodribb

About This Quote

This interpretation was drafted with AI assistance. It is one reading of the quote, not the author's own explanation.

The passage critiques how women are forced to work within male‑dominated theory, often compromising freedom for minimal gains.

In simple terms: Women navigate male‑centric academia, sacrificing autonomy for limited reward.

Key Takeaway

Recognize and resist exploitative academic structures.

Themes

feminism academia power dynamics gender critical theory

Mood

critical reflective analytical

Type

Academia:1 Computers:0 Feminism:1 Postmodernism:0 Poststructuralism:0 War:0 Male Theory:1 Immanent Critique:1 Masculinist Academic:1 Sexist Context:1 Male Academy:1

When to use this quote

  • university lecture
  • research collaboration
  • policy drafting
  • activist organizing

Key Concepts

immanent critique masculinist culture female agency institutional oppression

Questions to Reflect On

  • How can women transform male theory without losing autonomy?
  • What alternatives exist to the “war machine” model?
A Different Perspective

The analysis may overlook women’s agency in reshaping theory.

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ No ratings yet

More by Somer Brodribb

Explore all 2 Somer Brodribb quotes

More Academia quotes

Browse all 233 Academia quotes