Skip to content

It would be futile to delude ourselves that at present…

“It would be futile to delude ourselves that at present, readers find every pathography unsavory. This attitude is excused with the reproach that from a pathographic elaboration of a great man one never obtains an understanding of his importance and his attainments, that it is therefore useless…” quote by Sigmund Freud
Download Open image
““It would be futile to delude ourselves that at present, readers find every pathography unsavory. This attitude is excused with the reproach that from a pathographic elaboration of a great man one never obtains an understanding of his importance and his attainments, that it is therefore useless mischief to study in him things which could just as well be found in the first comer. However, this criticism is so clearly unjust that it can only be grasped when viewed as a pretext and a disguise for something. As a matter of fact pathography does not aim at making comprehensible the attainments of the great man; no one should really be blamed for not doing something which one never promised. The real motives for the opposition are quite different. One finds them when one bears in mind that biographers are fixed on their heroes in quite a peculiar manner. Frequently they take the hero as the object of study because, for reasons of their personal emotional life, they bear him a special affection from the very outset. They then devote themselves to a work of idealization which strives to enroll the great men among their infantile models, and to revive through him, as it were, the infantile conception of the father. For the sake of this wish they wipe out the individual features in his physiognomy, they rub out the traces of his life's struggle with inner and outer resistances, and do not tolerate in him anything of human weakness or imperfection; they then give us a cold, strange, ideal form instead of the man to whom we could feel distantly related. It is to be regretted that they do this, for they thereby sacrifice the truth to an illusion, and for the sake of their infantile phantasies they let slip the opportunity to penetrate into the most attractive secrets of human nature.””

Sigmund Freud

About This Quote

This interpretation was drafted with AI assistance. It is one reading of the quote, not the author's own explanation.

Freud argues that biographers idealize great figures, erasing flaws to fulfill personal fantasies, which distorts truth and blocks insight into human nature.

In simple terms: Biographers idealize heroes, hiding flaws and truth.

Key Takeaway

Seek authentic, nuanced portrayals.

Themes

psychology biography truth idealization human nature

Mood

critical analytical reflective

Type

philosophical inspirational

When to use this quote

  • academic critique
  • historical analysis
  • literary studies

Key Concepts

psychoanalysis hero worship narrative bias

Questions to Reflect On

  • How does idealizing heroes affect our understanding of humanity?
  • What can we learn from acknowledging a subject’s imperfections?
A Different Perspective

When studying influential people, beware of romanticized narratives that ignore their struggles.

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ No ratings yet

More by Sigmund Freud

Explore all 608 Sigmund Freud quotes

More Artist quotes

Browse all 32,600 Artist quotes