Skip to content

But hypnotism had been of immense help in the cathartic…

“But hypnotism had been of immense help in the cathartic treatment, by widening the field of the patient's consciousness and putting within his reach knowledge which he did not possess in his waking life. It seemed no easy task to find a substitute for it. While I was in this perplexity there came…” quote by Sigmund Freud
Download Open image
““But hypnotism had been of immense help in the cathartic treatment, by widening the field of the patient's consciousness and putting within his reach knowledge which he did not possess in his waking life. It seemed no easy task to find a substitute for it. While I was in this perplexity there came to my help the recollection of an experiment which I had often witnessed while I was with Bernheim. When the subject awoke from the state of somnambulism, he seemed to have lost all memory of what had happened while he was in that state. But Bernheim maintained that the memory was present all the same; and if he insisted on the subject remembering, if he asseverated that the subject knew it all and had only to say it, and if at the same time he laid his hand on the subject's forehead, then the forgotten memories used in fact to return, hesitatingly at first, but eventually in a flood and with complete clarity. I determined that I would act the same way. My patients I reflected, must in fact 'know' all the things which had hitherto only been made accessible to them in hypnosis; and assurances and encouragement on my part, assisted perhaps by the touch of my hand, would, I thought, have the power of forcing the forgotten facts and connections into consciousness. No doubt this seemed a more laborious process than putting the patients into hypnosis, but it might prove highly instructive. So I abandoned hypnotism, only retaining my practice of requiring the patient to lie upon a sofa while I sat behind him, seeing him, but not seen myself.””

Sigmund Freud

About This Quote

This interpretation was drafted with AI assistance. It is one reading of the quote, not the author's own explanation.

Freud describes replacing hypnosis with suggestion and therapeutic presence to retrieve forgotten memories, emphasizing conscious awareness over trance.

In simple terms: He tried to bring hidden memories to light without hypnosis, using suggestion and touch.

Key Takeaway

Use conscious suggestion and presence to access forgotten material.

Themes

psychotherapy memory consciousness suggestion

Mood

reflective analytical

Type

clinical theoretical historical

When to use this quote

  • clinical sessions
  • patient introspection
  • memory retrieval
  • non‑hypnotic therapy

Key Concepts

psychoanalysis hypnosis therapeutic alliance

Questions to Reflect On

  • Can suggestion replace hypnosis for all patients?
  • What role does therapist presence play in memory recovery?
A Different Perspective

May be less effective for deeply repressed material that benefits from trance states.

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ No ratings yet

More by Sigmund Freud

Explore all 608 Sigmund Freud quotes

More Hypnotism quotes

Browse all 13 Hypnotism quotes