Skip to content

Here is another weird example of the privileging of…

“Here is another weird example of the privileging of religion. On 21 February 2006 the United States Supreme Court ruled, in accordance with the Constitution, that a church in New Mexico should be exempt from the law, which everybody else has to obey, against the taking of hallucinogenic drugs…” quote by Richard Dawkins
Download Open image
““Here is another weird example of the privileging of religion. On 21 February 2006 the United States Supreme Court ruled, in accordance with the Constitution, that a church in New Mexico should be exempt from the law, which everybody else has to obey, against the taking of hallucinogenic drugs. Faithful members of Centro Espirita Beneficiente Uniao do Vegetal believe that they can understand God only by drinking dimethyltryptamine. Note that it is sufficient that they believe that the drug enhances their understanding. They do not have to produce evidence. Conversely, there is plenty of evidence that cannabis eases the nausea and discomfort of cancer sufferers undergoing chemotherapy. Yet, again in accordance with the Constitution, the Supreme Court ruled in 2005 that all patients who use cannabis for medicinal purposes are vulnerable to federal prosecution (even in the minority of states where such specialist use is legalized). Religion, as ever, is the trump card. Imagine members of an art appreciation society pleading in court they they 'believe' they need a hallucinogenic drug in order to enhance their understanding of Impressionist or Surrealist paintings. Yet, when a church claims an equivalent need, it is backed by the highest court in the land. Such is the power of religion as a talisman.””

Richard Dawkins

About This Quote

This interpretation was drafted with AI assistance. It is one reading of the quote, not the author's own explanation.

The ruling shows religious freedom can override drug regulations, granting churches exemptions not afforded to others, highlighting legal privilege of faith.

In simple terms: Religion can give legal advantages over secular needs.

Key Takeaway

Recognize how law treats religious claims differently.

Themes

religion law drug policy freedom inequality

Mood

critical thoughtful analytical

Type

legal philosophical controversial

When to use this quote

  • medical cannabis patients
  • religious ceremonies
  • art therapy
  • policy advocacy
  • legal challenges

Key Concepts

constitutional law religious liberty drug regulation legal privilege

Questions to Reflect On

  • Should religious belief outweigh public health concerns?
  • How can secular needs be fairly protected?
A Different Perspective

The decision may conflict with public health goals and equal protection principles.

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ No ratings yet

More by Richard Dawkins

Explore all 1,239 Richard Dawkins quotes

More Art appreciation quotes

Browse all 25 Art appreciation quotes