Skip to content

Why is it that women are the only ones who will write…

“Why is it that women are the only ones who will write perfect men into fiction? It's strange. If a man portrayed his fictional men as archangels, the feminists would throw back their heads and howl, "UNFAIR!" but we women will create our own Mr. Darcy's and Mr. Knightley's and defy anyone who…” quote by Rachel Heffington
Download Open image
““Why is it that women are the only ones who will write perfect men into fiction? It's strange. If a man portrayed his fictional men as archangels, the feminists would throw back their heads and howl, "UNFAIR!" but we women will create our own Mr. Darcy's and Mr. Knightley's and defy anyone who would point out their unrealistic points. The men aren't the ones crazy about Pride and Prejudice. Obviously they don't find perfect men realistic and honest enough to bother reading about. We don't write perfect women characters, do we? No. Our women all have bad tempers, or resentful hearts, or scabby pasts, or hidden fears--things that make them real. It's because we're easy on ourselves and aren't trying to boast perfection because we know we don't measure up. Then why do we hold men to a different standard?… I'd caution all writers to make sure that your male "hero" in your story has his own flaws. You don't want a one-dimensional character. You don't want a perfect man that will drive away other men from reading the book. Look to the men in your life. The men around you. Look to your brothers and fathers and pastors and neighbors. Your uncles and the guy down the street. Goodness--look to Taylor the Latte Boy if you must, but let's cast aside the Perfect-Man syndrome.””

Rachel Heffington

About This Quote

This interpretation was drafted with AI assistance. It is one reading of the quote, not the author's own explanation.

The author argues that writers often create flawless male characters while giving women realistic flaws, urging balanced, multidimensional male portrayals.

In simple terms: Women are given realistic flaws, men often idealized; writers should give men flaws too.

Key Takeaway

Give male characters believable imperfections.

Themes

gender stereotypes character development writing advice literary criticism

Mood

reflective critical inspirational

Type

advice literary critique philosophical

When to use this quote

  • novel writing
  • screenwriting
  • character workshops
  • editorial reviews

Key Concepts

idealization dimensionality authenticity

Questions to Reflect On

  • How can you portray a male hero with flaws without diminishing his appeal?
  • What benefits arise from more realistic male characters?
A Different Perspective

Some readers prefer escapist fantasy with perfect heroes, limiting relatability.

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ No ratings yet

More by Rachel Heffington

Explore all 25 Rachel Heffington quotes

More Bad temper quotes

Browse all 93 Bad temper quotes