At the same time, we may not as a culture be fond of…
““At the same time, we may not as a culture be fond of old-fashioned supernaturalism, but we certainly like spirituality in whatever form we can get it. I suspect that if anyone other than Jesus (Krishna, say, or Buddha) were suddenly put forward as being due for a second coming, millions in our postsecular society would embrace such a thing uncritically, leaving Enlightenment rationalism huffing and puffing in the rear. We are a puzzled and confused generation, embracing any and every kind of nonrationalism that may offer us a spiritual shot in the arm while lapsing back into rationalism (in particular, the old modernist critiques) whenever we want to keep traditional or orthodox Christianity at bay.””
About This Quote
This interpretation was drafted with AI assistance. It is one reading of the quote, not the author's own explanation.
Modern culture rejects traditional supernaturalism yet craves spirituality, leading to a paradoxical embrace of non‑rational ideas while occasionally reverting to rational critiques.
In simple terms: People want spiritual meaning but avoid old‑fashioned religion, creating a confusing mix.
Key Takeaway
Balance openness to spirituality with critical thinking.
Themes
spirituality
culture
modernity
paradox
rationalism
Mood
conflicted
thoughtful
Type
philosophical
analytical
When to use this quote
- personal belief crises
- media influence
- community rituals
- academic discourse
Key Concepts
secularism
post‑secularism
faith
critical theory
Questions to Reflect On
- How do you discern genuine spirituality?
- What role should rational critique play in faith?
A Different Perspective
Spirituality without discernment can lead to uncritical acceptance.