Give me a scholar, therefore, who is able to think and to…
““Give me a scholar, therefore, who is able to think and to write, to look with an eye of discernment into things, and to do business himself, if called upon, who hath both civil and military knowledge; one, moreover, who has been in camps, and has seen armies in the field and out of it; knows the use of arms, and machines, and warlike engines of every kind; can tell what the front, and what the horn is, how the ranks are to be disposed, how the horse is to be directed, and from whence to advance or to retreat; one, in short, who does not stay at home and trust to the reports of others: but, above all, let him be of a noble and liberal mind; let him neither fear nor hope for anything; otherwise he will only resemble those unjust judges who determine from partiality or prejudice, and give sentence for hire: but, whatever the man is, as such let him be described.””
About This Quote
This interpretation was drafted with AI assistance. It is one reading of the quote, not the author's own explanation.
A true scholar must combine intellectual rigor, practical experience, and moral independence, avoiding reliance on second‑hand reports and bias.
In simple terms: A scholar needs knowledge, experience, and impartial judgment.
Key Takeaway
Cultivate broad learning and independent thinking.
Themes
education
experience
ethics
leadership
independence
Mood
thoughtful
inspirational
critical
Type
philosophical
advice
reflective
When to use this quote
- political decision making
- military planning
- academic research
- journalism
- public policy
Key Concepts
philosophy
military strategy
critical thinking
Questions to Reflect On
- How can one balance breadth and depth in learning?
- What safeguards prevent bias in judgment?
A Different Perspective
May be unrealistic for individuals to master all fields; specialization can be valuable.