Skip to content

The notion that communism and Nazism are polar opposites…

“The notion that communism and Nazism are polar opposites stems from the deeper truth that they are in fact kindred spirits. Or, as Richard Pipes has written, "Bolshevism and Fascism were heresies of socialism". Both ideologies are reactionary in the sense that they try to re-create tribal…” quote by Jonah Goldberg
Download Open image
““The notion that communism and Nazism are polar opposites stems from the deeper truth that they are in fact kindred spirits. Or, as Richard Pipes has written, "Bolshevism and Fascism were heresies of socialism". Both ideologies are reactionary in the sense that they try to re-create tribal impulses. Communists champion class, Nazis race, fascists the nation. All such ideologies--we can call them totalitarian for now--attract the same types of people. Hitler's hatred for communism has been opportunistically exploited to signify ideological distance, when in fact it indicated the exact opposite. Today this maneuver has settled into conventional wisdom. But what Hitler hated about Marxism and communism had almost nothing to do with those aspects of communism that we would consider relevant, such as the economic doctrine or the need to destroy the capitalists and bourgeoisie. In these areas Hitler largely saw eye to eye with socialists and communists. His hatred stemmed from his paranoid conviction that the people calling themselves communists were in fact in on a foreign, Jewish conspiracy. He says this over and over again in Mein Kampf. He studied the names of communists and socialists, and if they sounded Jewish, that's all he needed to know. It was all a con job, a ruse, to destroy Germany. Only "authentically" German ideas from authentic Germans could be trusted. And when those Germans, like Feder or Strasser, proposed socialist ideas straight out of the Marxist playbook, he had virtually no objection whatsoever. Hitler never cared much about economics anyway. He always considered it "secondary". What mattered to him was German identity politics.””

Jonah Goldberg

About This Quote

This interpretation was drafted with AI assistance. It is one reading of the quote, not the author's own explanation.

The quote argues that communism and Nazism share fundamental similarities, being reactionary totalitarian ideologies that attract similar people, despite popular belief they are opposites.

In simple terms: Communism and Nazism are more alike than commonly thought.

Key Takeaway

Recognize ideological overlaps beyond surface differences.

Themes

politics history ideology totalitarianism comparative analysis

Mood

critical analytical skeptical

Type

analytical historical

When to use this quote

  • academic research
  • political discourse
  • education
  • media analysis
  • public policy

Key Concepts

reactionaryism tribalism identity politics conspiracy theory

Questions to Reflect On

  • How do we differentiate genuine ideological overlap from superficial similarities?
  • What evidence challenges the notion of shared tribal impulses?
A Different Perspective

The claim oversimplifies complex historical and economic differences between the systems.

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ No ratings yet

More by Jonah Goldberg

Explore all 171 Jonah Goldberg quotes

More Conventional wisdom quotes

Browse all 249 Conventional wisdom quotes