Skip to content

Blair ... argued that while he rejected doctrinaire…

“Blair ... argued that while he rejected doctrinaire “socialism,” he was committed to what he called “social-ism.” Blair’s hair-splitting got at an important distinction. Socialism, sprawling and inchoate as it may be, is still a doctrine. “Social-ism” is something different. It is an orientation…” quote by Jonah Goldberg
Download Open image
““Blair ... argued that while he rejected doctrinaire “socialism,” he was committed to what he called “social-ism.” Blair’s hair-splitting got at an important distinction. Socialism, sprawling and inchoate as it may be, is still a doctrine. “Social-ism” is something different. It is an orientation, a way of thinking about politics and governance—it is oriented toward government control but is not monomaniacally committed to it as the be-all and end-all. Social-ism is about what activists call “social justice,” which is always “progressive” and egalitarian but not invariably statist. As a practical matter, “social-ism” works from the assumption that well-intentioned leaders and planners are both smart enough and morally obliged to, in Obama’s words, “spread the wealth around” for the betterment of the whole society in general and the underprivileged in particular. But at a far more important level, “social-ism” is a fundamentally religious impulse, a utopian yearning to create a perfect society unconstrained by the natural trade-offs of mortal life. What Blair’s doctrinal revision recognizes is that public ownership of the means of production—the central economic principle of socialism—is not necessary as long as private interests and private businesses can be compelled to follow the designated road to utopia.””

Jonah Goldberg

About This Quote

This interpretation was drafted with AI assistance. It is one reading of the quote, not the author's own explanation.

Social-ism is an orientation toward social justice and government involvement without strict adherence to socialism’s doctrine of public ownership.

In simple terms: A flexible approach to progressive governance.

Key Takeaway

Consider pragmatic policies over rigid ideology.

Themes

politics ideology governance social justice utopianism

Mood

thoughtful critical analytical

Type

analytical philosophical political

When to use this quote

  • policy design
  • social reform
  • public‑private partnerships
  • wealth redistribution

Key Concepts

orientation pragmatism religious impulse utopian yearning

Questions to Reflect On

  • How can we balance idealism with realistic governance?
  • When does government intervention become counterproductive?
A Different Perspective

May overlook practical limits of government efficiency and individual freedom.

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ No ratings yet

More by Jonah Goldberg

Explore all 171 Jonah Goldberg quotes

More Capitalism quotes

Browse all 3,832 Capitalism quotes