Skip to content

we're looking for a planeet on the strength of a song…

“we're looking for a planeet on the strength of a song. it's crazy I know, but its the only chance we have to do something useful." ...Evan Wilson said gravely "I think you're as crazy as Heinrich Schliemann - and you know what happened to him!" "What" ... "you don't know what happened to him?" she…” quote by Janet Kagan
Download Open image
““we're looking for a planeet on the strength of a song. it's crazy I know, but its the only chance we have to do something useful." ...Evan Wilson said gravely "I think you're as crazy as Heinrich Schliemann - and you know what happened to him!" "What" ... "you don't know what happened to him?" she asked her blue eyes widening in astonishment."Ever read Homer's Iliad, Captain?" ... "I don't know what translation you read Doctor, but there was no Heinrich Schliemann in mine - or in the Odyssey." "That depends on how you look at it." smiling she settled back into her chair and went on,"Heinrich Schliemann was from Earth, pre-federation days, and he read Homer too. No, not just read him, believed him. So he set out at his own expense-mind you, I doubt he could have found anyone else to fund such a crazy endeavor - to find Troy, a city that most of the educated people of his time considered pure invention on Homer's part." "And?" "And he found it. Next time you're on earth, stop by the Troy Museum. the artifacts are magnificent, and every one of them was found on the strength of a song.””

Janet Kagan

About This Quote

This interpretation was drafted with AI assistance. It is one reading of the quote, not the author's own explanation.

The passage likens a song’s emotional power to a catalyst for discovering tangible, scientific breakthroughs, using Schliemann’s myth‑driven quest for Troy as a metaphor for daring, unconventional research.

In simple terms: Songs can inspire real discoveries.

Key Takeaway

Passion can drive scientific progress.

Themes

inspiration myth vs. history risk‑taking archaeology science communication creativity

Mood

wonder determination playfulness

Type

aphor dialogue historical reference

When to use this quote

  • scientists seeking funding for novel ideas
  • explorers interpreting ancient texts
  • students motivated by art
  • research teams facing skepticism

Key Concepts

song as catalyst Schliemann’s belief Troy’s historicity interdisciplinary insight

Practical Applications

  • using music to motivate research teams
  • framing projects with narrative to attract sponsors

Questions to Reflect On

  • What role does narrative play in scientific funding?
  • How can we balance skepticism with visionary ambition?
★ ★ ★ ★ ★ No ratings yet

More by Janet Kagan

Explore all 15 Janet Kagan quotes

More Educated people quotes

Browse all 182 Educated people quotes