Skip to content

It is odd what notions men seem to have of the scantiness…

“It is odd what notions men seem to have of the scantiness of a woman's resources. They do not find it anything out of nature that they should be able to exist by themselves; but a woman must always be borne about on somebody's shoulders, and dandled or chirped to, or it is supposed she will fall…” quote by Jane Welsh Carlyle
Download Open image
“It is odd what notions men seem to have of the scantiness of a woman's resources. They do not find it anything out of nature that they should be able to exist by themselves; but a woman must always be borne about on somebody's shoulders, and dandled or chirped to, or it is supposed she will fall into the blackest melancholy!”

Jane Welsh Carlyle

About This Quote

This interpretation was drafted with AI assistance. It is one reading of the quote, not the author's own explanation.

Women are socially dependent, expected to rely on men, leading to emotional instability if unsupported.

In simple terms: Women expected to rely on men; leads to melancholy.

Key Takeaway

Advocate for women's independence.

Themes

gender dependence social expectations

Mood

critical historical

Type

letter social critique

When to use this quote

  • marriage
  • career
  • social support

Key Concepts

feminist theory social critique

Questions to Reflect On

  • How can societies support women's autonomy?
  • What structures perpetuate dependence?
A Different Perspective

Historical view may overlook women's agency.

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ No ratings yet

More by Jane Welsh Carlyle

Explore all 49 Jane Welsh Carlyle quotes

More Able quotes

Browse all 17,257 Able quotes