Skip to content

On Aditya," First Citizen Yaggo declared, "there are no…

“On Aditya," First Citizen Yaggo declared, "there are no classes, and on Aditya everybody works. 'From each according to his ability; to each according to his need.'" "On Aditya," an elderly Counselor four places to the right of him said loudly to his neighbor, "they don't call them classes, they…” quote by H. Beam Piper
Download Open image
““On Aditya," First Citizen Yaggo declared, "there are no classes, and on Aditya everybody works. 'From each according to his ability; to each according to his need.'" "On Aditya," an elderly Counselor four places to the right of him said loudly to his neighbor, "they don't call them classes, they call them sociological categories, and they have nineteen of them. And on Aditya, they don't call them nonworkers, they call them occupational reservists, and they have more of them than we do." "But of course, I was born a king," Ranulf said sadly and nobly. "I have a duty to my people." "No, they don't vote at all," Lord Koreff was telling the Counselor on his left. "On Durendal, you have to pay taxes before you can vote." "On Aditya the crime of taxation does not exist," the First Citizen told the Prime Minister. "On Aditya," the Counselor four places down said to his neighbor, "there's nothing to tax. The state owns all the property, and if the Imperial Constitution and the Space Navy let them, the State would own all the people, too. Don't tell me about Aditya. First big-ship command I had was the old Invictus, 374, and she was based on Aditya for four years, and I'd sooner have spent that time in orbit around Niffelheim."... "But if they don't have votes to sell, what do they live on?" a Counselor asked in bewilderment. "The nobility supports them; the landowners, the trading barons, the industrial lords. The more nonworking adherents they have, the greater their prestige." And the more rifles they could muster when they quarreled with their fellow nobles, of course. "Beside, if we didn't do that, they'd turn brigand, and it costs less to support them than to have to hunt them out of the brush and hang them." "On Aditya, brigandage does not exist." "On Aditya, all the brigands belong to the Secret Police, only on Aditya they don't call them Secret Police, they call them Servants of the People, Ninth Category.””

H. Beam Piper

About This Quote

This interpretation was drafted with AI assistance. It is one reading of the quote, not the author's own explanation.

A society’s ideal of classlessness hides hidden hierarchies and control mechanisms

In simple terms: Even “classless” societies create new categories

Key Takeaway

Question the true structure of power

Themes

politics society control

Mood

critical thought‑provoking

Type

philosophical speculative

When to use this quote

  • Political analysis
  • science‑fiction world‑building
  • activism
  • education

Key Concepts

Marxist theory bureaucracy

Questions to Reflect On

  • What hidden categories exist in your community?
  • How does power manifest without formal titles?
A Different Perspective

Idealistic visions may mask oppression, requiring critical scrutiny

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ No ratings yet

More by H. Beam Piper

Explore all 27 H. Beam Piper quotes

More Body work quotes

Browse all 199 Body work quotes