Skip to content

I had the mistaken idea, based on what happened in World…

“I had the mistaken idea, based on what happened in World War I, that we would stay out of the war, and it is very unfortunate that I felt like that. If I had been more convinced, as Wigner and Szilard were, that we were going to get into the war, I would have pushed harder to begin making the…” quote by Gregory Benford
Download Open image
““I had the mistaken idea, based on what happened in World War I, that we would stay out of the war, and it is very unfortunate that I felt like that. If I had been more convinced, as Wigner and Szilard were, that we were going to get into the war, I would have pushed harder to begin making the bomb. I figured out that roughly half a million to a million people were being killed a month in the later stages of the war. Every month by which we could have shortened the war would have made a difference of a half million to a million lives, including the life of my own brother.””

Gregory Benford

About This Quote

This interpretation was drafted with AI assistance. It is one reading of the quote, not the author's own explanation.

He regretted not advocating for earlier development of the atomic bomb, believing it could have saved millions, including his brother, highlighting moral dilemmas in wartime decisions.

In simple terms: He wished he’d pushed for the bomb sooner to save lives.

Key Takeaway

Consider moral urgency in crisis decisions.

Themes

war ethics science responsibility family

Mood

somber thoughtful

Type

historical ethical

When to use this quote

  • policy advising
  • scientific advocacy
  • military strategy
  • family loss

Key Concepts

deterrence theory moral calculus historical hindsight

Questions to Reflect On

  • What responsibilities do scientists have in wartime?
  • How do personal losses influence policy views?
A Different Perspective

Accelerating weapon development raises ethical and geopolitical risks.

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ No ratings yet

More by Gregory Benford

Explore all 96 Gregory Benford quotes

More War quotes

Browse all 38,922 War quotes