One of our Church educators published what he purports to…
““One of our Church educators published what he purports to be a history of the Church's stand on the question of organic evolution. His thesis challenges the integrity of a prophet of God. He suggests that Joseph Fielding Smith published his work, Man: His Origin and Destiny, against the counsel of the First Presidency and his own Brethren. This writer's interpretation is not only inaccurate, but it also runs counter to the testimony of Elder Mark E. Petersen, who wrote this foreword to Elder Smith's book, a book I would encourage all to read. Elder Petersen said: Some of us [members of the Council of the Twelve] urged [Elder Joseph Fielding Smith] to write a book on the creation of the world and the origin of man… The present volume is the result. It is a most remarkable presentation of material from both sources [science and religion] under discussion. It will fill a great need in the Church and will be particularly invaluable to students who have become confused by the misapplication of information derived from scientific experimentation. When one understands that the author to whom I alluded is an exponent of the theory of organic evolution, his motive in disparaging President Joseph Fielding Smith becomes apparent. To hold to a private opinion on such matters is one thing, but when one undertakes to publish his views to discredit the work of a prophet, it is a very serious matter. It is also apparent to all who have the Spirit of God in them that Joseph Fielding Smith's writings will stand the test of time.””
About This Quote
This interpretation was drafted with AI assistance. It is one reading of the quote, not the author's own explanation.
The quote warns against using personal scientific opinions to undermine prophetic teachings, urging respect for official church doctrine and careful evaluation of sources.
In simple terms: Don’t let personal science attacks discredit religious leaders.
Respect doctrine; verify sources.
Themes
Mood
Type
When to use this quote
- personal belief
- academic critique
- church education
- public discourse
Key Concepts
Questions to Reflect On
- How should believers balance scientific inquiry with doctrinal authority?
- What criteria determine when a critique is constructive?
Personal opinions can be persuasive but may conflict with established teachings.