Skip to content

I can't help but recall, at this point, a horribly elitist…

“I can't help but recall, at this point, a horribly elitist but very droll remark by one of my favorite writers, the American "critic of the seven arts", James Huneker, in his scintillating biography of Frédéric Chopin, on the subject of Chopin's étude Op. 25, No. 11 in A minor, which for me, and…” quote by Douglas R. Hofstadter
Download Open image
““I can't help but recall, at this point, a horribly elitist but very droll remark by one of my favorite writers, the American "critic of the seven arts", James Huneker, in his scintillating biography of Frédéric Chopin, on the subject of Chopin's étude Op. 25, No. 11 in A minor, which for me, and for Huneker, is one of the most stirring and most sublime pieces of music ever written: “Small-souled men, no matter how agile their fingers, should avoid it.” "Small-souled men"?! Whew! Does that phrase ever run against the grain of American democracy! And yet, leaving aside its offensive, archaic sexism (a crime I, too, commit in GEB, to my great regret), I would suggest that it is only because we all tacitly do believe in something like Hueneker's' shocking distinction that most of us are willing to eat animals of one sort or another, to smash flies, swat mosquitos, fight bacteria with antibiotics, and so forth. We generally concur that "men" such as a cow, a turkey, a frog, and a fish all possess some spark of consciousness, some kind of primitive "soul" but by God, it's a good deal smaller than ours is — and that, no more and no less, is why we "men" feel that we have the perfect right to extinguish the dim lights in the heads of these fractionally-souled beasts and to gobble down their once warm and wiggling, now chilled and stilled protoplasm with limitless gusto, and not feel a trace of guilt while doing so.””

Douglas R. Hofstadter

About This Quote

This interpretation was drafted with AI assistance. It is one reading of the quote, not the author's own explanation.

The quote highlights a paradox: we claim moral concern for small animals yet dismiss the dignity of humans with modest abilities, exposing selective empathy.

In simple terms: We treat some beings as less worthy based on perceived ability.

Key Takeaway

Recognize and challenge arbitrary hierarchies of worth.

Themes

ethics humanism animal rights humility

Mood

reflective critical thoughtful

Type

philosophical inspirational

When to use this quote

  • dietary choices
  • animal welfare activism
  • educational curricula
  • personal reflection

Key Concepts

moral philosophy speciesism cognitive bias

Questions to Reflect On

  • Do you judge others by their abilities?
  • How can we extend compassion consistently?
A Different Perspective

The analogy may overgeneralize artistic skill to moral worth, which can be contested.

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ No ratings yet

More by Douglas R. Hofstadter

Explore all 14 Douglas R. Hofstadter quotes

More American democracy quotes

Browse all 168 American democracy quotes