Skip to content

Is there such a thing?' Birle asked. He looked…

“Is there such a thing?' Birle asked. He looked thoughtfully at her, but not as if he saw her. 'Men have dreamed of it, although none has ever held it in his hand, not to my knowledge. I cannot say that there is such a thing, no. But equally I cannot say there is not. Why should a man be able to…” quote by Cynthia Voigt
Download Open image
““Is there such a thing?' Birle asked. He looked thoughtfully at her, but not as if he saw her. 'Men have dreamed of it, although none has ever held it in his hand, not to my knowledge. I cannot say that there is such a thing, no. But equally I cannot say there is not. Why should a man be able to dream of it if it cannot be? If it is so impossible, then what put's it into a man's mind? Greed puts many things into men's mind, and fear does too. But men dream of other things, as well-- of justice, of the lost golden age, of an order to their world... of medicine to cure all sickness...””

Cynthia Voigt

About This Quote

This interpretation was drafted with AI assistance. It is one reading of the quote, not the author's own explanation.

The passage explores the tension between dreaming of impossible ideals and the human drive to imagine possibilities, acknowledging both fear and greed as motivators.

In simple terms: People dream of impossible things, driven by fear and greed.

Key Takeaway

Balance imagination with realistic goals.

Themes

dreams philosophy human nature fear greed

Mood

contemplative hopeful critical

Type

philosophical inspirational literary

When to use this quote

  • creative writing
  • personal reflection
  • philosophical debates
  • innovation sessions

Key Concepts

existentialism idealism psychology

Questions to Reflect On

  • What impossible ideas motivate you?
  • How do fear and greed shape your aspirations?
A Different Perspective

Dreams can inspire but also mislead without grounding.

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ No ratings yet

More by Cynthia Voigt

Explore all 78 Cynthia Voigt quotes

More Golden age quotes

Browse all 344 Golden age quotes