While [the Arians], like men sprung from a dunghill, truly…
![“While [the Arians], like men sprung from a dunghill, truly "spoke from the earth" [Jn. 3:31], the bishops [of Nicea], not having invented their phrases for themselves, but having testimony from their fathers, wrote as they did. For ancient bishops, of the great Rome and our city [i.e., Alexandria…” quote by Athanasius of Alexandria](https://sms4smile.com/q/i/06f/athanasius-of-alexandria-27473_alexandria_while-the-arians-like-men-sprung-from-a_1647814.jpg)
“While [the Arians], like men sprung from a dunghill, truly "spoke from the earth" [Jn. 3:31], the bishops [of Nicea], not having invented their phrases for themselves, but having testimony from their fathers, wrote as they did. For ancient bishops, of the great Rome and our city [i.e., Alexandria, Egypt, where Athanasius was bishop], some 130 years ago, wrote and censured those who said that the Son was a creature and not consubstantial with the Father.”
About This Quote
This interpretation was drafted with AI assistance. It is one reading of the quote, not the author's own explanation.
Early church leaders defended the doctrine of Christ’s divinity against claims of him being a created being, using inherited theological authority.
In simple terms: Ancient bishops affirmed Christ’s divine nature.
Key Takeaway
Uphold doctrinal continuity and authoritative tradition.
Themes
theology
authority
doctrine
historical debate
Mood
thoughtful
historical
Type
theological
doctrinal
When to use this quote
- church councils
- theological education
- faith formation
- inter‑denominational dialogue
Key Concepts
Trinitarian doctrine
hermeneutics
ecclesiastical authority
Questions to Reflect On
- What role should tradition play in modern belief?
- How can faith balance authority and inquiry?
A Different Perspective
Counterpoint: Relying on tradition can suppress legitimate questioning.