It is quite a startling proposition, and a very novel one…
“It is quite a startling proposition, and a very novel one, I think, that there shall be absolutely no opportunity for the review in an appellate court, in cases involving such large amounts, of questions involving the construction of the statute under which the court is proceeding, or those various questions of law, many of them new, which necessarily arise in such cases.Neither the claimants, the Indians, nor the Government of the United States should beabsolutely denied opportunityto bring their exceptions to review by some appellate tribunal.”
About This Quote
This interpretation was drafted with AI assistance. It is one reading of the quote, not the author's own explanation.
The quote argues that appellate courts must retain the right to review large, complex cases involving new legal questions, ensuring fairness for all parties.
In simple terms: Appellate courts should review big, novel cases for fairness.
Key Takeaway
Preserve appellate review for complex cases.
Themes
justice
fairness
legal process
appellate review
Mood
concerned
critical
Type
legal
opinion
When to use this quote
- large financial litigation
- government contracts
- native claims
- new legal doctrines
Key Concepts
jurisprudence
constitutional law
procedural rights
Questions to Reflect On
- How can courts balance efficiency with thorough review?
- What safeguards ensure consistent appellate oversight?
A Different Perspective
May be overly broad, lacking specific procedural guidance.