---
title: "Meaning & Key Takeaway of: Incompatibilists will tell you that a…"
description: "\"Incompatibilists will tell you that a work of art has no meaning unless the artists could have chosen to create a different one, but actual artists oft..."
image: "https://sms4smile.com/quotes/i/d06/nomy-arpaly-21717_art_incompatibilists-will-tell-you-that-a-wo_830092.jpg"
---

#  Incompatibilists will tell you that a work of art has no…

![“Incompatibilists will tell you that a work of art has no meaning unless the artists could have chosen to create a different one, but actual artists often say things like &quot;the book chose me&quot; - that is, the work had to be. Some philosophers would call it &quot;volitional necessity&quot;, and a similar case…” quote by Nomy Arpaly](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/i/d06/nomy-arpaly-21717_art_incompatibilists-will-tell-you-that-a-wo_830092.jpg)   [Download](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/i/d06/nomy-arpaly-21717_art_incompatibilists-will-tell-you-that-a-wo_830092.jpg) [Open image](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/i/d06/nomy-arpaly-21717_art_incompatibilists-will-tell-you-that-a-wo_830092.jpg)

> “Incompatibilists will tell you that a work of art has no meaning unless the artists could have chosen to create a different one, but actual artists often say things like "the book chose me" - that is, the work had to be. Some philosophers would call it "volitional necessity", and a similar case that's discussed is the case of Luther saying "here I stand, I can do no other".”

[Nomy Arpaly](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/author/nomy-arpaly/)

## About This Quote

This interpretation was drafted with AI assistance. It is one reading of the quote, not the author's own explanation.

The quote argues that artistic meaning can be seen as inevitable, not a matter of choice, contrasting philosophical volitional necessity with the notion that creators are compelled by forces beyond their control.

**In simple terms:** Art can feel predetermined rather than chosen.

Key Takeaway

Recognize that some creations feel inevitable.

Themes

art philosophy meaning free will

Mood

reflective introspective

Type

philosophical inspirational

When to use this quote

- artist interviews
- art criticism
- creative workshops
- philosophical debates

Key Concepts

volitional necessity determinism creative compulsion

Questions to Reflect On

- Do you feel your work was inevitable?
- How does this view affect artistic responsibility?

A Different Perspective

It may overlook the role of conscious intent in art.

★ ★ ★ ★ ★   No ratings yet

[Art](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/about/art/) [Art Meaning](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/about/art-meaning-550636/) [Artist](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/about/artist/) [Book](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/about/book/) [Books](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/about/books/) [Chosen](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/about/chosen/) [Different](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/about/different/) [Incompatibilists Tell](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/about/incompatibilists-tell-550633/) [Luther](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/about/luther/) [Necessity](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/about/necessity/) [Philosopher](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/about/philosopher/) [Philosophers Volitional](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/about/philosophers-volitional-550635/) [Volitional Necessity](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/about/volitional-necessity-550634/)

## Related quotes

> [“Among the hardest problems an art theory faces are questions about how to settle art’s meaning through interpretation”](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/cynthia-freeland/among-the-hardest-problems-an-art-theory-faces-are-questions-about/)

[Cynthia Freeland](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/author/cynthia-freeland/)

> [When art seems to be empty of meaning, as no doubt some of the abstract painting of our own day actually does seem, what…](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/lewis-mumford/when-art-seems-to-be-empty-of-meaning-as-no-doubt-some-of-the/)

[Lewis Mumford](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/author/lewis-mumford/)

> [Art—the meaning of the pattern of our common actions in reality. The cloth-of-gold that hides behind the sackcloth of reality, forced out by the…](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/lawrence-durrell/art-the-meaning-of-the-pattern-of-our-common-actions-in-reality-the/)

[Lawrence Durrell](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/author/lawrence-durrell/)

> [“Revealing aspects of the mystery of being human is life's inexhaustible research. Through the adventures of art, we find the meaning of our lives.”](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/ashley-bryan/revealing-aspects-of-the-mystery-of-being-human-is-life-s/)

[Ashley Bryan](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/author/ashley-bryan/)

> [Art is the meaning of my life.](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/jack-conte/art-is-the-meaning-of-my-life/)

[Jack Conte](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/author/jack-conte/)

> [What gives my art the most meaning is when I can connect with others through it. When people say that my music has helped…](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/lindsey-stirling/what-gives-my-art-the-most-meaning-is-when-i-can-connect-with-others/)

[Lindsey Stirling](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/author/lindsey-stirling/)

> [“I know. You think you love art because you have a sensitive soul. Isn't a sensitive soul simply a means of transforming a deficiency…](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/rabih-alameddine/i-know-you-think-you-love-art-because-you-have-a-sensitive-soul-isn-t/)

[Rabih Alameddine](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/author/rabih-alameddine/)

> [If I am told my loving you had to happen because of some Freudian stuff about my childhood, that might be degrading or deflationary,…](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/nomy-arpaly/if-i-am-told-my-loving-you-had-to-happen-because-of-some-freudian/)

[Nomy Arpaly](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/author/nomy-arpaly/)

> [All he said was that we're all free if we pursue spirit. That's all he said. He didn't say let's set up a Vatican…](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/frederick-lenz/all-he-said-was-that-we-re-all-free-if-we-pursue-spirit-that-s-all-he/)

[Frederick Lenz](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/author/frederick-lenz/)

> [Most students graduate from high school knowing nine words about the civil rights movement: Rosa Parks, Martin Luther King, and "I Have a Dream."…](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/andrew-aydin/most-students-graduate-from-high-school-knowing-nine-words-about-the/)

[Andrew Aydin](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/author/andrew-aydin/)

> [I don't think anything happens without the press, one way or the other. I think it's all done for it. You saw it start,…](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/garry-winogrand/i-don-t-think-anything-happens-without-the-press-one-way-or-the-other/)

[Garry Winogrand](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/author/garry-winogrand/)

> [“It was easy for you to say these things, since you either knew you were not writing to Luther, but for the general public,…](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/martin-luther/it-was-easy-for-you-to-say-these-things-since-you-either-knew-you/)

[Martin Luther](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/author/martin-luther/)

> [What is accurately portrayed is the rich humanity not just of Martin Luther King but of the movement, which was a multiracial movement. You…](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/cornel-west/what-is-accurately-portrayed-is-the-rich-humanity-not-just-of-martin/)

[Cornel West](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/author/cornel-west/)

> [The God in whose hands are all our days and ways, did cast into my hand one day a book of Martin Luthers; it…](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/john-bunyan/the-god-in-whose-hands-are-all-our-days-and-ways-did-cast-into-my/)

[John Bunyan](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/author/john-bunyan/)

> [I cannot forbid a person to marry several wives, for it does not contradict Scripture. MARTIN LUTHER, letter to Chancellor Gregory Brück, January 13,…](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/jean-de-la-bruyere/i-cannot-forbid-a-person-to-marry-several-wives-for-it-does-not/)

[Jean de la Bruyere](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/author/jean-de-la-bruyere/)

## More by Nomy Arpaly

> [I am an atheist. I don't think there's anything divine. Beautiful, impressive, awe-inspiring - sure, but not divine.](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/nomy-arpaly/i-am-an-atheist-i-don-t-think-there-s-anything-divine-beautiful/)

[Nomy Arpaly](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/author/nomy-arpaly/)

> [Other things being equal, ill will is worse than moral indifference (as in causing suffering for money vs causing suffering to cause suffering), though…](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/nomy-arpaly/other-things-being-equal-ill-will-is-worse-than-moral-indifference-as/)

[Nomy Arpaly](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/author/nomy-arpaly/)

> [Duties concern things that are voluntary. I do think that if you have a moral duty to bring me back the book you borrowed,…](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/nomy-arpaly/duties-concern-things-that-are-voluntary-i-do-think-that-if-you-have/)

[Nomy Arpaly](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/author/nomy-arpaly/)

> [Sometimes I suspect that there are two prototypes of philosophers who write about humans - I call them "celestials" and "terrestrials", without implying that…](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/nomy-arpaly/sometimes-i-suspect-that-there-are-two-prototypes-of-philosophers-who/)

[Nomy Arpaly](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/author/nomy-arpaly/)

> [When you find yourself reluctant to sit on a chair because it had unexpectedly collapsed in the past you might shake your head and…](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/nomy-arpaly/when-you-find-yourself-reluctant-to-sit-on-a-chair-because-it-had/)

[Nomy Arpaly](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/author/nomy-arpaly/)

> [If I make a stupid decision but don't execute it because I'm, say, lazy, then I'm lucky, not rational. However, at other times a…](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/nomy-arpaly/if-i-make-a-stupid-decision-but-don-t-execute-it-because-i-m-say-lazy/)

[Nomy Arpaly](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/author/nomy-arpaly/)

> [If I am told my loving you had to happen because of some Freudian stuff about my childhood, that might be degrading or deflationary,…](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/nomy-arpaly/if-i-am-told-my-loving-you-had-to-happen-because-of-some-freudian/)

[Nomy Arpaly](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/author/nomy-arpaly/)

> [I am not committed in any way to the traditional concept of character - the concept of "character trait" as involving predictable behavior. I…](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/nomy-arpaly/i-am-not-committed-in-any-way-to-the-traditional-concept-of-character/)

[Nomy Arpaly](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/author/nomy-arpaly/)

> [I don't think any of my desires or beliefs or other mental states are external to me. Many people will occasionally feel alienated from…](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/nomy-arpaly/i-don-t-think-any-of-my-desires-or-beliefs-or-other-mental-states-are/)

[Nomy Arpaly](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/author/nomy-arpaly/)

> [Though we think intrinsic desires tend to be pretty stable, we do not think they imply anything like the amount of predictability in behavior…](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/nomy-arpaly/though-we-think-intrinsic-desires-tend-to-be-pretty-stable-we-do-not/)

[Nomy Arpaly](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/author/nomy-arpaly/)

> [Suppose a student of mine writes in her exam that "morality is completely relative to culture, so nothing is absolutely right or wrong. Because…](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/nomy-arpaly/suppose-a-student-of-mine-writes-in-her-exam-that-morality-is/)

[Nomy Arpaly](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/author/nomy-arpaly/)

> [I don't think we are all irrational every time we fail to see through an argument in a book, but suppose it's true about…](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/nomy-arpaly/i-don-t-think-we-are-all-irrational-every-time-we-fail-to-see-through/)

[Nomy Arpaly](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/author/nomy-arpaly/)

> [I think it's ok to have wishes that conflict with each other - it's irrational to try to make them both come true, but…](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/nomy-arpaly/i-think-it-s-ok-to-have-wishes-that-conflict-with-each-other-it-s/)

[Nomy Arpaly](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/author/nomy-arpaly/)

> [When I see two owls and then two more owls and conclude that I see four owls, I am responding to reasons, and it…](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/nomy-arpaly/when-i-see-two-owls-and-then-two-more-owls-and-conclude-that-i-see/)

[Nomy Arpaly](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/author/nomy-arpaly/)

> [The fact that only humans above a certain age can be morally virtuous, rather than babies or cats, means that that being moral requires…](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/nomy-arpaly/the-fact-that-only-humans-above-a-certain-age-can-be-morally-virtuous/)

[Nomy Arpaly](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/author/nomy-arpaly/)

[Explore all 28 Nomy Arpaly quotes ](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/author/nomy-arpaly/)

## More Art quotes

> [True works of art contain their own theory and give us the measurement according to which we should judge them.](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/johann-wolfgang-von-goethe/true-works-of-art-contain-their-own-theory-and-give-us-the/)

[Johann Wolfgang von Goethe](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/author/johann-wolfgang-von-goethe/)

> [Before Noah, men having only water to drink, could not find the truth. Accordingly...they became abominably wicked, and they were justly exterminated by the…](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/benjamin-franklin/before-noah-men-having-only-water-to-drink-could-not-find-the-truth/)

[Benjamin Franklin](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/author/benjamin-franklin/)

> [“Hear the sum of the whole matter in the compass of one brief word — every art possessed by man comes from Prometheus.”](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/aeschylus/hear-the-sum-of-the-whole-matter-in-the-compass-of-one-brief-word/)

[Aeschylus](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/author/aeschylus/)

> [I think most artists feel like they're outside society - no matter how many accolades they receive, or how much money is in your…](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/aaron-rose/i-think-most-artists-feel-like-they-re-outside-society-no-matter-how/)

[Aaron Rose](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/author/aaron-rose/)

> [The capacity to be puzzled is the premise of all creation, be it in art or in science.](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/erich-fromm/the-capacity-to-be-puzzled-is-the-premise-of-all-creation-be-it-in/)

[Erich Fromm](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/author/erich-fromm/)

> [That's the great secret of creativity. You treat ideas like cats: you make them follow you.](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/ray-bradbury/that-s-the-great-secret-of-creativity-you-treat-ideas-like-cats-you/)

[Ray Bradbury](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/author/ray-bradbury/)

> [“So, really," continued Jacob as if this were perfectly normal to expound on art in these circumstances, "when you think about it, the artists…](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/justina-chen-headley/so-really-continued-jacob-as-if-this-were-perfectly-normal-to-expound/)

[Justina Chen Headley](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/author/justina-chen-headley/)

> [“There are two options in art; either to adopt philosophical life by dissecting art, or to write your own philosophical life and claim it…](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/taf-teh/there-are-two-options-in-art-either-to-adopt-philosophical-life-by/)

[Taf Teh](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/author/taf-teh/)

> [The house has to serve comfort. The work of art is revolutionary; the house is conservative.](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/adolf-loos/the-house-has-to-serve-comfort-the-work-of-art-is-revolutionary-the/)

[Adolf Loos](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/author/adolf-loos/)

> [During human progress, every science is evolved out of its corresponding art.](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/herbert-spencer/during-human-progress-every-science-is-evolved-out-of-its/)

[Herbert Spencer](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/author/herbert-spencer/)

> [In literature and art memory is a synonym for invention. It is the life-blood of imagination, which faints and dies when the veins are…](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/robert-aris-willmott/in-literature-and-art-memory-is-a-synonym-for-invention-it-is-the/)

[Robert Aris Willmott](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/author/robert-aris-willmott/)

> [I think a business guy is different from an artist. They walk different paths. Artists create the best outputs when they're having fun. And…](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/g-dragon/i-think-a-business-guy-is-different-from-an-artist-they-walk/)

[G-Dragon](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/author/g-dragon/)

> [“The only thing--I tell you this straight from the heart--that disgusts me in Salzburg is that one can't have any proper social intercourse with…](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/wolfgang-amadeus-mozart/the-only-thing-i-tell-you-this-straight-from-the-heart-that-disgusts/)

[Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/author/wolfgang-amadeus-mozart/)

> [The sublime in art is the attempt to express the infinite without finding in the realm of phenomena any object which proves itself fitting…](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/georg-wilhelm-friedrich-hegel/the-sublime-in-art-is-the-attempt-to-express-the-infinite-without/)

[Georg Wilhelm Friedrich Hegel](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/author/georg-wilhelm-friedrich-hegel/)

> [Art isn't done to decorate apartments, but to wage war against the enemy.](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/pablo-picasso/art-isn-t-done-to-decorate-apartments-but-to-wage-war-against-the/)

[Pablo Picasso](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/author/pablo-picasso/)

[Browse all 48,643 Art quotes ](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/about/art/)

```json
{
    "@context": "https://schema.org",
    "@graph": [
        {
            "@type": "Quotation",
            "text": "Incompatibilists will tell you that a work of art has no meaning unless the artists could have chosen to create a different one, but actual artists often say things like \"the book chose me\" - that is, the work had to be. Some philosophers would call it \"volitional necessity\", and a similar case that's discussed is the case of Luther saying \"here I stand, I can do no other\".",
            "creator": {
                "@type": "Person",
                "name": "Nomy Arpaly"
            },
            "isPartOf": {
                "@id": "https://sms4smile.com/quotes/#website"
            },
            "url": "https://sms4smile.com/quotes/nomy-arpaly/incompatibilists-will-tell-you-that-a-work-of-art-has-no-meaning/",
            "about": {
                "@type": "Thing",
                "name": "Art"
            },
            "@id": "https://sms4smile.com/quotes/nomy-arpaly/incompatibilists-will-tell-you-that-a-work-of-art-has-no-meaning/#quotation",
            "image": {
                "@type": "ImageObject",
                "@id": "https://sms4smile.com/quotes/i/d06/nomy-arpaly-21717_art_incompatibilists-will-tell-you-that-a-wo_830092.jpg",
                "contentUrl": "https://sms4smile.com/quotes/i/d06/nomy-arpaly-21717_art_incompatibilists-will-tell-you-that-a-wo_830092.jpg",
                "url": "https://sms4smile.com/quotes/i/d06/nomy-arpaly-21717_art_incompatibilists-will-tell-you-that-a-wo_830092.jpg",
                "width": 1080,
                "height": 1080,
                "caption": "“Incompatibilists will tell you that a work of art has no meaning unless the artists could have chosen to…” — Nomy Arpaly",
                "creditText": "SMS4Smile Quotes",
                "creator": {
                    "@id": "https://sms4smile.com/quotes/#organization"
                }
            }
        },
        {
            "@type": "BreadcrumbList",
            "itemListElement": [
                {
                    "@type": "ListItem",
                    "position": 1,
                    "name": "Home",
                    "item": "https://sms4smile.com/"
                },
                {
                    "@type": "ListItem",
                    "position": 2,
                    "name": "Quotes",
                    "item": "https://sms4smile.com/quotes/"
                },
                {
                    "@type": "ListItem",
                    "position": 3,
                    "name": "Nomy Arpaly",
                    "item": "https://sms4smile.com/quotes/author/nomy-arpaly/"
                },
                {
                    "@type": "ListItem",
                    "position": 4,
                    "name": "Incompatibilists will tell you that a...",
                    "item": "https://sms4smile.com/quotes/nomy-arpaly/incompatibilists-will-tell-you-that-a-work-of-art-has-no-meaning/"
                }
            ],
            "@id": "https://sms4smile.com/quotes/nomy-arpaly/incompatibilists-will-tell-you-that-a-work-of-art-has-no-meaning/#breadcrumb"
        },
        {
            "@type": "WebSite",
            "@id": "https://sms4smile.com/quotes/#website",
            "name": "SMS4Smile Quotes",
            "url": "https://sms4smile.com/quotes/",
            "publisher": {
                "@id": "https://sms4smile.com/quotes/#organization"
            }
        },
        {
            "@type": "Organization",
            "@id": "https://sms4smile.com/quotes/#organization",
            "name": "SMS4Smile Quotes",
            "url": "https://sms4smile.com/quotes/",
            "logo": {
                "@type": "ImageObject",
                "url": "https://sms4smile.com/quotes/wp-content/themes/sq/assets/icons/icon-512.png",
                "width": 512,
                "height": 512
            }
        }
    ]
}
```
