--- title: "Meaning & Key Takeaway of: By arguing that the bundle theory does…" description: "\"By arguing that the bundle theory does not entail and is not committed in any way to the principle of identity of indiscernibles, I have thereby defend..." image: "https://sms4smile.com/quotes/i/f1f/gonzalo-rodriguez-pereyra-2539_arguing_by-arguing-that-the-bundle-theory-does-n_712458.jpg" --- # By arguing that the bundle theory does not entail and is… ![“By arguing that the bundle theory does not entail and is not committed in any way to the principle of identity of indiscernibles, I have thereby defended the bundle theory from a traditional objection to it.” quote by Gonzalo Rodriguez-Pereyra](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/i/f1f/gonzalo-rodriguez-pereyra-2539_arguing_by-arguing-that-the-bundle-theory-does-n_712458.jpg) [Download](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/i/f1f/gonzalo-rodriguez-pereyra-2539_arguing_by-arguing-that-the-bundle-theory-does-n_712458.jpg) [Open image](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/i/f1f/gonzalo-rodriguez-pereyra-2539_arguing_by-arguing-that-the-bundle-theory-does-n_712458.jpg) > “By arguing that the bundle theory does not entail and is not committed in any way to the principle of identity of indiscernibles, I have thereby defended the bundle theory from a traditional objection to it.” [Gonzalo Rodriguez-Pereyra](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/author/gonzalo-rodriguez-pereyra/) ## About This Quote This interpretation was drafted with AI assistance. It is one reading of the quote, not the author's own explanation. The author argues that bundle theory avoids the principle of identity of indiscernibles, defending it against traditional objections **In simple terms:** Bundle theory can be defended without invoking identity of indiscernibles Key Takeaway Consider alternative metaphysical frameworks Themes philosophy metaphysics identity Mood analytical thoughtful Type academic theoretical When to use this quote - academic seminars - philosophy courses - debate clubs - research papers Key Concepts bundle theory principle of indiscernibility Questions to Reflect On - How does rejecting indiscernibility affect our understanding of objects? - What are practical implications of bundle theory? A Different Perspective Complex arguments may be inaccessible to non‑specialists ★ ★ ★ ★ ★ No ratings yet [Identity](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/about/identity/) [Objections](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/about/objections/) [Principles](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/about/principles/) ## Related quotes > [I do not believe in the bundle theory anyway. The bundle theory postulates universals and I do not believe in them; so I do…](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/gonzalo-rodriguez-pereyra/i-do-not-believe-in-the-bundle-theory-anyway-the-bundle-theory/) [Gonzalo Rodriguez-Pereyra](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/author/gonzalo-rodriguez-pereyra/) > [ In 1975, ... \[speaking with Shiing Shen Chern\], I told him I had finally learned ... the beauty of fiber-bundle theory and the profound… ](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/chen-ning-yang/in-1975-speaking-with-shiing-shen-chern-i-told-him-i-had-finally/) Chen-Ning Yang > [For bundles of universals can be in more than one place at the same time; so a bundle can have more than one instance;…](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/gonzalo-rodriguez-pereyra/for-bundles-of-universals-can-be-in-more-than-one-place-at-the-same/) [Gonzalo Rodriguez-Pereyra](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/author/gonzalo-rodriguez-pereyra/) > [In my view the bundle theorist should say that when a bundle is located somewhere, there is an 'instance' of the bundle there. The…](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/gonzalo-rodriguez-pereyra/in-my-view-the-bundle-theorist-should-say-that-when-a-bundle-is/) [Gonzalo Rodriguez-Pereyra](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/author/gonzalo-rodriguez-pereyra/) > [“An objection which applies to all conduct can be no valid objection to any conduct in particular.”](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/john-stuart-mill/an-objection-which-applies-to-all-conduct-can-be-no-valid-objection/) [John Stuart Mill](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/author/john-stuart-mill/) > [Man's objection to love is that it dies hard; woman's, that when it is dead, it stays dead.](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/h-l-mencken/man-s-objection-to-love-is-that-it-dies-hard-woman-s-that-when-it-is/) [H. L. Mencken](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/author/h-l-mencken/) > [In Japan, I live in a little neighborhood in the middle of nowhere. I don't have a bicycle or a car or anything, so…](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/pico-iyer/in-japan-i-live-in-a-little-neighborhood-in-the-middle-of-nowhere-i/) [Pico Iyer](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/author/pico-iyer/) > [“If you take an objection in the ‘relative’, it is intellectual rationalism. ‘We’ don’t have intellectual rationalism. ‘We’ are abuddha (do not have intellect)…](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/dada-bhagwan/if-you-take-an-objection-in-the-relative-it-is-intellectual/) [Dada Bhagwan](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/author/dada-bhagwan/) > [The commonest objection to birth control is that it is against nature.](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/bertrand-russell/the-commonest-objection-to-birth-control-is-that-it-is-against-nature/) [Bertrand Russell](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/author/bertrand-russell/) > [I think my wife would take objection to any characterization of me as perfect.](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/peter-blair-henry/i-think-my-wife-would-take-objection-to-any-characterization-of-me-as/) [Peter Blair Henry](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/author/peter-blair-henry/) > [I have no objection to the concept of domestic partnership.](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/rudy-giuliani/i-have-no-objection-to-the-concept-of-domestic-partnership/) [Rudy Giuliani](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/author/rudy-giuliani/) > [My great objection to this government is, that it does not leave us the means of defending our rights, or of waging war against…](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/patrick-henry/my-great-objection-to-this-government-is-that-it-does-not-leave-us/) [Patrick Henry](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/author/patrick-henry/) > [I have spoken to many, many Indian chiefs who say they have no objection whatsoever to the nickname.](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/anonymous/i-have-spoken-to-many-many-indian-chiefs-who-say-they-have-no/) [Anonymous](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/author/anonymous/) > [“To a strong, proven salesperson, an objection is as welcomed as a rain shower on a hot day because it proves that the client…](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/anonymous/to-a-strong-proven-salesperson-an-objection-is-as-welcomed-as-a-rain/) [Anonymous](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/author/anonymous/) > [Everything is allowable in literature, but what is not allowable in criticism is objection on the grounds of probability.](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/howard-jacobson/everything-is-allowable-in-literature-but-what-is-not-allowable-in/) [Howard Jacobson](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/author/howard-jacobson/) ## More by Gonzalo Rodriguez-Pereyra > [The parallelism, or denial of any causation between mind and body, derives basically, and fallaciously, from a theory of substances as having complete concepts…](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/gonzalo-rodriguez-pereyra/the-parallelism-or-denial-of-any-causation-between-mind-and-body/) [Gonzalo Rodriguez-Pereyra](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/author/gonzalo-rodriguez-pereyra/) > [In my view the bundle theorist should say that when a bundle is located somewhere, there is an 'instance' of the bundle there. The…](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/gonzalo-rodriguez-pereyra/in-my-view-the-bundle-theorist-should-say-that-when-a-bundle-is/) [Gonzalo Rodriguez-Pereyra](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/author/gonzalo-rodriguez-pereyra/) > [I would say I was a philosophical boy. Thoughts about 'identical stones' are the earliest philosophical thoughts I remember. But when I was a…](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/gonzalo-rodriguez-pereyra/i-would-say-i-was-a-philosophical-boy-thoughts-about-identical-stones/) [Gonzalo Rodriguez-Pereyra](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/author/gonzalo-rodriguez-pereyra/) > [There are different interpretations of the problem of universals. I understand it as the problem of giving the truthmakers of propositions to the effect…](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/gonzalo-rodriguez-pereyra/there-are-different-interpretations-of-the-problem-of-universals-i/) [Gonzalo Rodriguez-Pereyra](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/author/gonzalo-rodriguez-pereyra/) > [Those who think that metaphysics is just misunderstood grammar will react to my giving metaphysics some place or another in the system of knowledge.](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/gonzalo-rodriguez-pereyra/those-who-think-that-metaphysics-is-just-misunderstood-grammar-will/) [Gonzalo Rodriguez-Pereyra](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/author/gonzalo-rodriguez-pereyra/) > [At one point I took a copy of Berkeley's Principles from my father's library. That was the first philosophy book I read. I found…](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/gonzalo-rodriguez-pereyra/at-one-point-i-took-a-copy-of-berkeley-s-principles-from-my-father-s/) [Gonzalo Rodriguez-Pereyra](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/author/gonzalo-rodriguez-pereyra/) > [Imperfect communities show that being a maximal resemblance class is not sufficient for being a property.](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/gonzalo-rodriguez-pereyra/imperfect-communities-show-that-being-a-maximal-resemblance-class-is/) [Gonzalo Rodriguez-Pereyra](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/author/gonzalo-rodriguez-pereyra/) > [I decided to do philosophy at university, with a view to becoming a professional philosopher. Being a rather unstable character, at some points I…](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/gonzalo-rodriguez-pereyra/i-decided-to-do-philosophy-at-university-with-a-view-to-becoming-a/) [Gonzalo Rodriguez-Pereyra](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/author/gonzalo-rodriguez-pereyra/) > [The difference between resemblance nominalism and class nominalism is that the former, but not the latter, brings in resemblance to account for the truthmakers…](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/gonzalo-rodriguez-pereyra/the-difference-between-resemblance-nominalism-and-class-nominalism-is/) [Gonzalo Rodriguez-Pereyra](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/author/gonzalo-rodriguez-pereyra/) > [A truthmaker is an entity in virtue of which the proposition it makes true is true. And it is a necessary condition of being…](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/gonzalo-rodriguez-pereyra/a-truthmaker-is-an-entity-in-virtue-of-which-the-proposition-it-makes/) [Gonzalo Rodriguez-Pereyra](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/author/gonzalo-rodriguez-pereyra/) > [The huge majority of philosophers seem to think that including impure properties in the range of the quantifiers of the principle would make the…](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/gonzalo-rodriguez-pereyra/the-huge-majority-of-philosophers-seem-to-think-that-including-impure/) [Gonzalo Rodriguez-Pereyra](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/author/gonzalo-rodriguez-pereyra/) > [The role of metaphysics in relation to other disciplines, whether philosophical or not and including the natural sciences, is thus a foundational role. Lack…](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/gonzalo-rodriguez-pereyra/the-role-of-metaphysics-in-relation-to-other-disciplines-whether/) [Gonzalo Rodriguez-Pereyra](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/author/gonzalo-rodriguez-pereyra/) > [For bundles of universals can be in more than one place at the same time; so a bundle can have more than one instance;…](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/gonzalo-rodriguez-pereyra/for-bundles-of-universals-can-be-in-more-than-one-place-at-the-same/) [Gonzalo Rodriguez-Pereyra](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/author/gonzalo-rodriguez-pereyra/) > [Metaphysics is the study of the most general nature and basic structure of reality, and therefore the concepts of metaphysics, concepts like time, space,…](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/gonzalo-rodriguez-pereyra/metaphysics-is-the-study-of-the-most-general-nature-and-basic/) [Gonzalo Rodriguez-Pereyra](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/author/gonzalo-rodriguez-pereyra/) > [Those who take knowledge to be a whole zoo of sub-disciplines will react to my giving metaphysics a privileged position in that zoo or…](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/gonzalo-rodriguez-pereyra/those-who-take-knowledge-to-be-a-whole-zoo-of-sub-disciplines-will/) [Gonzalo Rodriguez-Pereyra](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/author/gonzalo-rodriguez-pereyra/) [Explore all 23 Gonzalo Rodriguez-Pereyra quotes ](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/author/gonzalo-rodriguez-pereyra/) ## More Arguing quotes > [I do wish you wouldn't argue with me when I'm knitting.](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/gerald-durrell/i-do-wish-you-wouldn-t-argue-with-me-when-i-m-knitting/) [Gerald Durrell](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/author/gerald-durrell/) > [Any comprehensive doctrine, religious or secular, can be introduced into any political argument at any time, but I argue that people who do this…](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/john-rawls/any-comprehensive-doctrine-religious-or-secular-can-be-introduced/) [John Rawls](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/author/john-rawls/) > [It's fine to talk about politics with people you agree with. But it is rude to argue about politics with people you disagree with.…](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/lawrence-lessig/it-s-fine-to-talk-about-politics-with-people-you-agree-with-but-it-is/) [Lawrence Lessig](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/author/lawrence-lessig/) > [Men are fair, and they have learned not to personalize anger - they can disagree with you and argue to the bone, but afterward…](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/warren-farrell/men-are-fair-and-they-have-learned-not-to-personalize-anger-they-can/) [Warren Farrell](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/author/warren-farrell/) > [When Eudæmonidas heard a philosopher arguing that only a wise man can be a good general, "This is a wonderful speech," said he; "but…](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/plutarch/when-eud-monidas-heard-a-philosopher-arguing-that-only-a-wise-man-can/) [Plutarch](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/author/plutarch/) > [Fasting is required, staying away from fighting and arguing and bombing of masjids is still going on. Hatred is still manifested between Sunni and…](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/louis-farrakhan/fasting-is-required-staying-away-from-fighting-and-arguing-and/) [Louis Farrakhan](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/author/louis-farrakhan/) > [The problem for the Left, however, is that the moment it stops painting the Right as vile, it has to argue the issues.](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/dennis-prager/the-problem-for-the-left-however-is-that-the-moment-it-stops-painting/) [Dennis Prager](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/author/dennis-prager/) > [To argue with a person who has renounced the use of reason is like administering medicine to the dead.](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/thomas-paine/to-argue-with-a-person-who-has-renounced-the-use-of-reason-is-like/) [Thomas Paine](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/author/thomas-paine/) > [You can argue that the Terminator movies reboot their world each time they go back in time, but that doesn't negate the value of…](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/david-hayter/you-can-argue-that-the-terminator-movies-reboot-their-world-each-time/) [David Hayter](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/author/david-hayter/) > [We may argue eloquently that 'Honesty is the best Policy' - unfortunately, the moment honesty is adopted for the sake of policy it mysteriously…](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/dorothy-l-sayers/we-may-argue-eloquently-that-honesty-is-the-best-policy-unfortunately/) [Dorothy L. Sayers](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/author/dorothy-l-sayers/) > [I'm a very serious person, but I don't take myself very seriously and I would rather laugh all day than argue.](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/stone-cold-steve-austin/i-m-a-very-serious-person-but-i-don-t-take-myself-very-seriously-and/) [Stone Cold Steve Austin](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/author/stone-cold-steve-austin/) > [These eyes, tho' clear To outward view of blemish or of spot, Bereft of light, their seeing have forgot, Nor to their idle orbs…](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/john-milton/these-eyes-tho-clear-to-outward-view-of-blemish-or-of-spot-bereft-of/) [John Milton](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/author/john-milton/) > [There's crucial distinction that has to be drawn between the Shari'a, which is this hugely expansive vision of cosmic order that I've been describing,…](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/sadakat-kadri/there-s-crucial-distinction-that-has-to-be-drawn-between-the-shari-a/) [Sadakat Kadri](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/author/sadakat-kadri/) > [Only fools argue whether to eat meat or not. They don't understand truth nor do they meditate on it. Who can define what is…](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/guru-nanak/only-fools-argue-whether-to-eat-meat-or-not-they-don-t-understand/) [Guru Nanak](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/author/guru-nanak/) > [The surest sign that you haven't any sense is to argue with one who hasn't.](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/laurence-j-peter/the-surest-sign-that-you-haven-t-any-sense-is-to-argue-with-one-who/) [Laurence J. Peter](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/author/laurence-j-peter/) Browse all 1,908 Arguing quotes ```json { "@context": "https://schema.org", "@graph": [ { "@type": "Quotation", "text": "By arguing that the bundle theory does not entail and is not committed in any way to the principle of identity of indiscernibles, I have thereby defended the bundle theory from a traditional objection to it.", "creator": { "@type": "Person", "name": "Gonzalo Rodriguez-Pereyra" }, "isPartOf": { "@id": "https://sms4smile.com/quotes/#website" }, "url": "https://sms4smile.com/quotes/gonzalo-rodriguez-pereyra/by-arguing-that-the-bundle-theory-does-not-entail-and-is-not/", "about": { "@type": "Thing", "name": "Arguing" }, "@id": "https://sms4smile.com/quotes/gonzalo-rodriguez-pereyra/by-arguing-that-the-bundle-theory-does-not-entail-and-is-not/#quotation", "image": { "@type": "ImageObject", "@id": "https://sms4smile.com/quotes/i/f1f/gonzalo-rodriguez-pereyra-2539_arguing_by-arguing-that-the-bundle-theory-does-n_712458.jpg", "contentUrl": "https://sms4smile.com/quotes/i/f1f/gonzalo-rodriguez-pereyra-2539_arguing_by-arguing-that-the-bundle-theory-does-n_712458.jpg", "url": "https://sms4smile.com/quotes/i/f1f/gonzalo-rodriguez-pereyra-2539_arguing_by-arguing-that-the-bundle-theory-does-n_712458.jpg", "width": 1080, "height": 1080, "caption": "“By arguing that the bundle theory does not entail and is not committed in any way to the principle of…” — Gonzalo Rodriguez-Pereyra", "creditText": "SMS4Smile Quotes", "creator": { "@id": "https://sms4smile.com/quotes/#organization" } } }, { "@type": "BreadcrumbList", "itemListElement": [ { "@type": "ListItem", "position": 1, "name": "Home", "item": "https://sms4smile.com/" }, { "@type": "ListItem", "position": 2, "name": "Quotes", "item": "https://sms4smile.com/quotes/" }, { "@type": "ListItem", "position": 3, "name": "Gonzalo Rodriguez-Pereyra", "item": "https://sms4smile.com/quotes/author/gonzalo-rodriguez-pereyra/" }, { "@type": "ListItem", "position": 4, "name": "By arguing that the bundle theory...", "item": "https://sms4smile.com/quotes/gonzalo-rodriguez-pereyra/by-arguing-that-the-bundle-theory-does-not-entail-and-is-not/" } ], "@id": "https://sms4smile.com/quotes/gonzalo-rodriguez-pereyra/by-arguing-that-the-bundle-theory-does-not-entail-and-is-not/#breadcrumb" }, { "@type": "WebSite", "@id": "https://sms4smile.com/quotes/#website", "name": "SMS4Smile Quotes", "url": "https://sms4smile.com/quotes/", "publisher": { "@id": "https://sms4smile.com/quotes/#organization" } }, { "@type": "Organization", "@id": "https://sms4smile.com/quotes/#organization", "name": "SMS4Smile Quotes", "url": "https://sms4smile.com/quotes/", "logo": { "@type": "ImageObject", "url": "https://sms4smile.com/quotes/wp-content/themes/sq/assets/icons/icon-512.png", "width": 512, "height": 512 } } ] } ```