--- title: "Meaning & Key Takeaway of: Debbie Nathan blames the early symptoms…" description: "\"“Debbie Nathan blames the early symptoms on pernicious anemia yet explains their supposed remission by Shirley’s being out of contact with Dr. Wilbur f..." image: "https://sms4smile.com/quotes/i/bbd/colin-a-ross-35098_dissociative-identit_debbie-nathan-blames-the-early-symptoms_265207.jpg" --- # Debbie Nathan blames the early symptoms on pernicious… ![“Debbie Nathan blames the early symptoms on pernicious anemia yet explains their supposed remission by Shirley’s being out of contact with Dr. Wilbur for those 9 years. But Dr. Wilbur never diagnosed a dissociative disorder in 1945. Nathan does not seem to recognize the implausibility of Dr. Wilbur…” quote by Colin A. Ross](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/i/bbd/colin-a-ross-35098_dissociative-identit_debbie-nathan-blames-the-early-symptoms_265207.jpg) [Download](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/i/bbd/colin-a-ross-35098_dissociative-identit_debbie-nathan-blames-the-early-symptoms_265207.jpg) [Open image](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/i/bbd/colin-a-ross-35098_dissociative-identit_debbie-nathan-blames-the-early-symptoms_265207.jpg) > ““Debbie Nathan blames the early symptoms on pernicious anemia yet explains their supposed remission by Shirley’s being out of contact with Dr. Wilbur for those 9 years. But Dr. Wilbur never diagnosed a dissociative disorder in 1945. Nathan does not seem to recognize the implausibility of Dr. Wilbur creating via suggestion a complex dissociative disorder in five sessions, particularly when the doctor herself did not diagnose it. Nathan attributes Shirley’s postintegration improvement in functioning to being out of contact with Dr. Wilbur rather than to the therapy. But the pernicious anemia continued to be undiagnosed and untreated during that time period, so any symptoms due to it should have continued rather than showing an improvement that coincided with psychotherapy with Dr. Wilbur. Debbie Nathan’s thesis is self-contradictory.”” [Colin A. Ross](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/author/colin-a-ross/) ## About This Quote This interpretation was drafted with AI assistance. It is one reading of the quote, not the author's own explanation. The critique points out logical inconsistencies in Nathan’s explanation of patient symptoms and treatment outcomes. **In simple terms:** Nathan’s argument contains contradictions about diagnosis and recovery. Key Takeaway Question the validity of the presented causal links. Themes medical criticism logic diagnosis therapy contradiction Mood skeptical analytical Type critical academic When to use this quote - psychiatric case review - medical research - clinical teaching - patient care - evidence evaluation Key Concepts causal inference clinical reasoning diagnostic error Questions to Reflect On - How does one verify causal claims in clinical case studies? - What other factors could explain the patient’s improvement? A Different Perspective The argument may overlook alternative explanations for symptom changes. ★ ★ ★ ★ ★ No ratings yet [Abuse](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/about/abuse/) [Dissociative-identity-disorder](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/about/dissociative-identity-disorder/) [Implausible](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/about/implausible/) [Multiple personality disorder](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/about/multiple-personality-disorder/) [Pseudoscience](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/about/pseudoscience/) [Sybil](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/about/sybil/) ## Related quotes > [ “Interestingly, the patients who presented to me self-diagnosed \[with Dissociative Identity Disorder\] had tried to tell previous therapists of their plight, but had been… ](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/richard-p-kluft/interestingly-the-patients-who-presented-to-me-self-diagnosed-with/) [Richard P. Kluft](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/author/richard-p-kluft/) > [“Treating Abuse Today 3(4) pp. 26-33 TAT: I want to move back to an area that I'm not real comfortable asking you about, but…](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/david-l-calof/treating-abuse-today-3-4-pp-26-33-tat-i-want-to-move-back-to-an-area/) [David L. Calof](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/author/david-l-calof/) > [“Treating Abuse Today 3(4) pp. 26-33 Freyd: The term "multiple personality" itself assumes that there is "single personality" and there is evidence that no…](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/david-l-calof/treating-abuse-today-3-4-pp-26-33-freyd-the-term-multiple-personality/) [David L. Calof](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/author/david-l-calof/) ## More by Colin A. Ross > [“On December 11, 1996 in a posting on the internet list WITCHNT@MITVMA.MIT.EDU, Dr Peter Freyd, husband of the Executive Directory of the False Memory…](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/colin-a-ross/on-december-11-1996-in-a-posting-on-the-internet-list-witchnt-mitvma/) [Colin A. Ross](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/author/colin-a-ross/) > [“There have been extensive human rights violations by American psychiatrists over the last 70 years. These doctors were pad by the American taxpayer through…](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/colin-a-ross/there-have-been-extensive-human-rights-violations-by-american/) [Colin A. Ross](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/author/colin-a-ross/) > [“Dr. Lois Jolyon West was cleared at Top Secret for his work on MKULTRA. West's numerous connections to the mind control network illustrate how…](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/colin-a-ross/dr-lois-jolyon-west-was-cleared-at-top-secret-for-his-work-on-mkultra/) [Colin A. Ross](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/author/colin-a-ross/) > [“The major goal of the Cold War mind control programs was to create dissociative symptoms and disorders, including full multiple personality disorder. The Manchurian…](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/colin-a-ross/the-major-goal-of-the-cold-war-mind-control-programs-was-to-create/) [Colin A. Ross](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/author/colin-a-ross/) > [“A problem is that Nathan documents Shirley Mason as suffering from a variety of symptoms of a complex dissociative disorder prior to her first…](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/colin-a-ross/a-problem-is-that-nathan-documents-shirley-mason-as-suffering-from-a/) [Colin A. Ross](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/author/colin-a-ross/) > [“Undiagnosed DID patients received incorrect diagnoses of schizophrenia in 25% to 40% of cases in two large series (Putnam, 1989; Ross, 1989), while in…](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/colin-a-ross/undiagnosed-did-patients-received-incorrect-diagnoses-of/) [Colin A. Ross](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/author/colin-a-ross/) > [“The second factor helping to bring the dissociative disorders back into the mainstream was the Vietnam War. For sociological reasons originating outside psychology and…](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/colin-a-ross/the-second-factor-helping-to-bring-the-dissociative-disorders-back/) [Colin A. Ross](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/author/colin-a-ross/) > [“Debbie Nathan also puts a great deal of weight on a letter from Shirley Mason to Dr. Wilbur stating that her MPD was made…](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/colin-a-ross/debbie-nathan-also-puts-a-great-deal-of-weight-on-a-letter-from/) [Colin A. Ross](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/author/colin-a-ross/) > [ “\[ Dr. Lois Jolyon West was cleared at Top Secret for his work on MKULTRA. \] Dr. Michael Persinger \[235\], another FSMF Board Member,… ](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/colin-a-ross/dr-lois-jolyon-west-was-cleared-at-top-secret-for-his-work-on-mkultra-2/) [Colin A. Ross](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/author/colin-a-ross/) > [“Dr. Louis Jolyon “Jolly” West was born in New York City on October 6, 1924. He died of cancer on January 2, 1999. Dr.…](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/colin-a-ross/dr-louis-jolyon-jolly-west-was-born-in-new-york-city-on-october-6/) [Colin A. Ross](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/author/colin-a-ross/) > [“Debbie Nathan’s thesis is that Shirley Mason was a vulnerable hysteric and was manipulated by her therapist into iatrogenic DID and false memories of…](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/colin-a-ross/debbie-nathan-s-thesis-is-that-shirley-mason-was-a-vulnerable/) [Colin A. Ross](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/author/colin-a-ross/) > [“As a single case from half a century ago, Sybil Exposed cannot tell us anything about the reliability, validity, etiology, epidemiology, or typical treatment…](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/colin-a-ross/as-a-single-case-from-half-a-century-ago-sybil-exposed-cannot-tell-us/) [Colin A. Ross](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/author/colin-a-ross/) [Explore all 13 Colin A. Ross quotes ](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/author/colin-a-ross/) ## More Abuse quotes > [I wrote when I was a young teen, but I didn't put an eye on the available markets until I was seventeen. The next…](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/robert-reed/i-wrote-when-i-was-a-young-teen-but-i-didn-t-put-an-eye-on-the/) [Robert Reed](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/author/robert-reed/) > [Amongst the financial Twitterati, the term 'muppets' has come to describe any client used and abused by some financial predator. I've adopted the term…](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/barry-ritholtz/amongst-the-financial-twitterati-the-term-muppets-has-come-to/) [Barry Ritholtz](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/author/barry-ritholtz/) > [Being nice is okay,but don't allow anybody to abuse it...try to fight for your self when you know your on the right way...](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/anonymous/being-nice-is-okay-but-don-t-allow-anybody-to-abuse-it-try-to-fight/) [Anonymous](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/author/anonymous/) > [“Build a bridge over shame by teaching kids about sexual abuse. Give them a chance to run to us should they encounter it. Be…](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/carolyn-byers-ruch/build-a-bridge-over-shame-by-teaching-kids-about-sexual-abuse-give/) [Carolyn Byers Ruch](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/author/carolyn-byers-ruch/) > [It is sure that those are most desirous of honour or glory who cry out loudest of its abuse and the vanity of the…](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/baruch-spinoza/it-is-sure-that-those-are-most-desirous-of-honour-or-glory-who-cry/) [Baruch Spinoza](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/author/baruch-spinoza/) > [“The sole reason I stand to open it up now is that lots of people who are in pain just like I was, and…](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/patricia-dsouza/the-sole-reason-i-stand-to-open-it-up-now-is-that-lots-of-people-who/) [Patricia Dsouza](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/author/patricia-dsouza/) > [Democracy must be built through open societies that share information. When there is information, there is enlightenment. When there is debate, there are solutions.…](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/atifete-jahjaga/democracy-must-be-built-through-open-societies-that-share-information/) [Atifete Jahjaga](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/author/atifete-jahjaga/) > [I have a theory that all abuse, no matter what kind of abuse it is, is foremost an assault on the mind.](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/tara-westover/i-have-a-theory-that-all-abuse-no-matter-what-kind-of-abuse-it-is-is/) [Tara Westover](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/author/tara-westover/) > [“Blaming therapy, social work and other caring professions for the confabulation of testimony of 'satanic ritual abuse' legitimated a programme of political and social…](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/michael-salter/blaming-therapy-social-work-and-other-caring-professions-for-the/) [Michael Salter](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/author/michael-salter/) > [Finally, the scariest thing about abuse of any shape or form, is, in my opinion, not the abuse itself, but that if it continues…](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/alan-cumming/finally-the-scariest-thing-about-abuse-of-any-shape-or-form-is-in-my/) [Alan Cumming](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/author/alan-cumming/) > [“Research on organised abuse emphasises the diversity of organised abuse cases, and the ways in which serious forms of child maltreatment cluster in the…](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/michael-salter/research-on-organised-abuse-emphasises-the-diversity-of-organised/) [Michael Salter](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/author/michael-salter/) > [“Stand up for yourself. Never give any one permission to abuse you.”](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/lailah-gifty-akita/stand-up-for-yourself-never-give-any-one-permission-to-abuse-you/) [Lailah Gifty Akita](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/author/lailah-gifty-akita/) > [All governments should be pressured to correct their abuses of human rights.](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/richard-stallman/all-governments-should-be-pressured-to-correct-their-abuses-of-human/) [Richard Stallman](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/author/richard-stallman/) > [“Words are free. It does not mean you should abuse them. Be kind with them. They will mirror your actions.”](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/hadinet-tekie/words-are-free-it-does-not-mean-you-should-abuse-them-be-kind-with/) [Hadinet Tekie](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/author/hadinet-tekie/) > [My illness is one often characterized by dramatic overspending - in my case through frenzied shopping sprees, credit card abuse, excessive hoarding of unnecessary…](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/andy-behrman/my-illness-is-one-often-characterized-by-dramatic-overspending-in-my/) [Andy Behrman](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/author/andy-behrman/) [Browse all 3,113 Abuse quotes ](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/about/abuse/) ```json { "@context": "https://schema.org", "@graph": [ { "@type": "Quotation", "text": "“Debbie Nathan blames the early symptoms on pernicious anemia yet explains their supposed remission by Shirley’s being out of contact with Dr. Wilbur for those 9 years. But Dr. Wilbur never diagnosed a dissociative disorder in 1945. Nathan does not seem to recognize the implausibility of Dr. Wilbur creating via suggestion a complex dissociative disorder in five sessions, particularly when the doctor herself did not diagnose it. Nathan attributes Shirley’s postintegration improvement in functioning to being out of contact with Dr. Wilbur rather than to the therapy. But the pernicious anemia continued to be undiagnosed and untreated during that time period, so any symptoms due to it should have continued rather than showing an improvement that coincided with psychotherapy with Dr. Wilbur. Debbie Nathan’s thesis is self-contradictory.”", "creator": { "@type": "Person", "name": "Colin A. Ross" }, "isPartOf": { "@id": "https://sms4smile.com/quotes/#website" }, "url": "https://sms4smile.com/quotes/colin-a-ross/debbie-nathan-blames-the-early-symptoms-on-pernicious-anemia-yet/", "about": { "@type": "Thing", "name": "Abuse" }, "@id": "https://sms4smile.com/quotes/colin-a-ross/debbie-nathan-blames-the-early-symptoms-on-pernicious-anemia-yet/#quotation", "image": { "@type": "ImageObject", "@id": "https://sms4smile.com/quotes/i/bbd/colin-a-ross-35098_dissociative-identit_debbie-nathan-blames-the-early-symptoms_265207.jpg", "contentUrl": "https://sms4smile.com/quotes/i/bbd/colin-a-ross-35098_dissociative-identit_debbie-nathan-blames-the-early-symptoms_265207.jpg", "url": "https://sms4smile.com/quotes/i/bbd/colin-a-ross-35098_dissociative-identit_debbie-nathan-blames-the-early-symptoms_265207.jpg", "width": 1080, "height": 1080, "caption": "“Debbie Nathan blames the early symptoms on pernicious anemia yet explains their supposed remission by…” — Colin A. Ross", "creditText": "SMS4Smile Quotes", "creator": { "@id": "https://sms4smile.com/quotes/#organization" } } }, { "@type": "BreadcrumbList", "itemListElement": [ { "@type": "ListItem", "position": 1, "name": "Home", "item": "https://sms4smile.com/" }, { "@type": "ListItem", "position": 2, "name": "Quotes", "item": "https://sms4smile.com/quotes/" }, { "@type": "ListItem", "position": 3, "name": "Colin A. Ross", "item": "https://sms4smile.com/quotes/author/colin-a-ross/" }, { "@type": "ListItem", "position": 4, "name": "“Debbie Nathan blames the early symptoms...", "item": "https://sms4smile.com/quotes/colin-a-ross/debbie-nathan-blames-the-early-symptoms-on-pernicious-anemia-yet/" } ], "@id": "https://sms4smile.com/quotes/colin-a-ross/debbie-nathan-blames-the-early-symptoms-on-pernicious-anemia-yet/#breadcrumb" }, { "@type": "WebSite", "@id": "https://sms4smile.com/quotes/#website", "name": "SMS4Smile Quotes", "url": "https://sms4smile.com/quotes/", "publisher": { "@id": "https://sms4smile.com/quotes/#organization" } }, { "@type": "Organization", "@id": "https://sms4smile.com/quotes/#organization", "name": "SMS4Smile Quotes", "url": "https://sms4smile.com/quotes/", "logo": { "@type": "ImageObject", "url": "https://sms4smile.com/quotes/wp-content/themes/sq/assets/icons/icon-512.png", "width": 512, "height": 512 } } ] } ```